The Trouble With Financial Dependence

by In: Leadership | Published: Apr 28, 2010

I attend a small lib­eral arts col­lege in the North­east. To be frank, our busi­ness man­ager is new and didn’t con­sult old appli­ca­tions for SGA fund­ing. Our EIC sub­mit­ted our appli­ca­tion two days late. We received zero fund­ing, and we need $10,000 per semes­ter in order to print. Unless we can raise that amount some­how, we have no news­pa­per. (We do have a great web­site thanks to cer­tain out­stand­ing, very enter­pris­ing peo­ple on our team. But we want a news­pa­per too. Most peo­ple would.)

So the prob­lem is less finan­cial depen­dence and more incom­pe­tence. I acknowl­edge that. At the same time, I was just elected EIC, and so I have to clean up this mess. I’m learn­ing about con­tin­gency fund­ing and deals we might make with our pub­lisher. But I was hop­ing to ben­e­fit from your advice and exper­tise. I apol­o­gize for not being able to be more spe­cific. Thanks for any and all help.

 

About mnash

Editor in Chief of The Mount Holyoke News. We have weathered financial disasters, relaunched our website, sold ad packages, caught plagiarism, worked hard, cried, clung to our last shred of morale, restructured our staff, recruited awesome people and allowed less-than-awesome people to silently drift away.
 
 

10 Responses

  1. Maybe this is an oppor­tu­nity in dis­guise. If you have an out­stand­ing site, why not make it even bet­ter? Become a leader in col­lege news­pa­pers and drop the “paper” part of it. There are a lot of things you can do with a web­site, espe­cially social media and inter­ac­tive media, that you might not have been able to ded­i­cate to because of run­ning the actual paper part of it.

    What­ever money you do get, spend it on adver­tis­ing for the web site. Next year/semester, when you do get that $10,000, think how much fur­ther it will go when your bud­get just dropped one of its most expen­sive items.

    I under­stand your loss, and it does suck, but maybe find­ing the silver-lining will be your way to recover.

    These, of course, are just my opinions :)

  2. Prodigybiz says:

    Hey there,

    I was in your shoes just a few months ago. I am the Busi­ness Man­ager for The Prodigy at the Uni­ver­sity of Cal­i­for­nia Merced. I was asked to take on this posi­tion back in Jan­u­ary after the pre­vi­ous BM left/graduated. We had no money and next to no ads. It looks grim, but its not.
    We have a web­site, but it does not have con­tent at all so that avenue wasn’t really an option for us.
    The good news is we are thriv­ing after 3 months with 8 grand in the bank and more on the way. It just takes work.
    I have some tips and I am will­ing to help your Busi­ness Man­ager. Just because you are not a line item on your stu­dent government’s bud­get its not the end of the world. Write a bill, talk to some sen­a­tors and the Pres­i­dent and explain why the news­pa­per is so impor­tant to your school’s cul­ture– they will do it. If not then that’s a story! They may not give you the 10 grand for each semes­ter you need, but they will prob­a­bly throw you a life­saver.
    Next thing is AD rev­enue. I assume dur­ing the sum­mer you prac­ti­cally shut down. Busi­ness peo­ple should be out there sell­ing ads. I can def­i­nitely give tips and tricks there. You will get enough money to print trust me you will.
    How often do you print?
    Fill Free to email or call me
    kellis3@ucmerced.edu or 209.580.6546
    –send me your rate card and I will see what all i can do for you.
    Don’t worry, if you have some ded­i­cated peo­ple you will survive. :)

  3. mnash says:

    Thanks so much for your help! I’m relieved to say that SGA is will­ing to work with us. In any case, I’ll pass your info along to our Publisher-Elect.

  4. Steve Fox says:

    There is no doubt you should be able to get spe­cial con­sid­er­a­tion — this is not a club to go out and have fun. Ask­ing for the “reg­u­lar” fund­ing to keep the news­pa­per going is vital to a uni­ver­sity.
    There is no way a SG wants to have the death of the long-time cam­pus news­pa­per on their hands. You can have a field day writ­ing that — that two days late was the death of the paper with not fur­ther consideration.

  5. mnash says:

    I think you’re right. I was coun­seled to play it safe until we actu­ally received con­tin­gency funding.

    This is just a stu­pid sit­u­a­tion. The Col­lege isn’t going to let this stand, and if they do, we should have fun get­ting this to UWIRE. At the same time, we failed to hold our EIC account­able after some obscene breaches of ethics this year. We should have seen some­thing like this coming.

  6. Fund­ing for news­pa­pers is always an issue. If you have an adver­tis­ing staff with some con­fi­dence, there are a few places that often get over­looked that may be inter­ested in buy­ing an ad or two.

    Churches, espe­cially youth groups want to keep kids com­ing to their ser­vices.
    Auto­mo­tive repair shops,
    Bars and restau­rants, depend­ing on your alco­hol adver­tis­ing pol­icy, don’t be afraid to say, “Do you have a drink spe­cial or event?” This one should be obvi­ous though.
    Finally, com­mu­nity or town­ship events. There are parades, farmer’s mar­kets, fes­ti­vals and all kinds of cool stuff. Get them to buy a big one and list the whole cal­en­dar. (You’ll prob­a­bly be writ­ing sto­ries about these anyway)

    While $10,000 from Stu Gov would be nice, they may only be able to give you $8,000 or less. Who knows. Going out and get­ting those ads, brings in a lit­tle money and the expe­ri­ence is good, puts a face with a paper for busi­nesses and builds good­will. Also, the more money you have, the more cool stuff you can do. (Sadly true)

    Keep us posted on this… other papers are strug­gling finan­cially and some of your expe­ri­ence could be an inter­est­ing post on here when you’ve got it resolved.

  7. mnash says:

    We need $10,000 over­all, but it doesn’t have to come from SGA, espe­cially if we’re mak­ing cuts and rais­ing more revenue.

    The Ways & Means Com­mit­tee approved our revised bud­get yes­ter­day. Sen­ate will vote on SGA’s con­tin­gency fund­ing bud­get in Sep­tem­ber, which includes the allo­ca­tion of $14,909.75 to the stu­dent news­pa­per. The bud­get will likely pass, and in future years, we’ll prob­a­bly be made a line item on their budget.

    How­ever, we are mak­ing some adjust­ments that I hope will bring in some money for the web­site. We’ll be sell­ing $10 print ads (to appear on the Events page) to stu­dent orgs. If we sell three per week, we should have nearly $1000 by the end of the year. We’ve also cut our dis­tri­b­u­tion man­ager posi­tion. Next year, mem­bers of staff will take turns dis­trib­ut­ing the newspaper.

    Web adver­tis­ing is the next step. Also love the idea about com­mu­nity events. We’ll be con­tact­ing the Gar­lic Fes­ti­val plan­ners shortly!

  8. Prodigybiz says:

    sounds like you are doing much bet­ter. All its takes is hard work and ded­i­ca­tion. Pay­roll is a great place to cut. My paper is com­pletely vol­un­teer.
    When you do web ads, the best way to do them is to pack­age it with print. When I was at con­fer­ence, it was rec­om­mended not charg­ing extra for them because you don’t want to fee your clients to death. If you ad another perk they may buy a big­ger ad.

    Good luck :)

  9. Prodigybiz says:

    Hey, just curi­ous to see how you are doing.
    I would assume classes start in about a month or so for you.
    Drop me a line.
    Hope­fully we might meet up at con­fer­ence in Louisville.

  10. Prodigybiz says:

    Hey, just curi­ous to see how you are doing.
    I would assume classes start in about a month or so for you.
    let me know how you are dong.
    Hope­fully we might meet up at con­fer­ence in Louisville.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.