Accuracy
This was recently posted, in a longer version, on a listserv. Any ideas:
This year, we have seen a precipitous decline in our accuracy standards. Hardly a day goes by without a correction or three.
Part of it, I think, is that it’s never been easier for readers and sources to point out our mistakes. I think other factors include editors who are too busy multitasking to really think critically during the editing process, writers who are disengaged, stories that come in too close to deadline for good vetting and potentially, a process with so many fail-safes that no one takes ownership.
Here is what we are already doing:
–Reporters are required to put CQs in their stories that list of the source of info on each fact.
–Every story is edited by three line editors, then two copy editors .
–Pages are checked by top editors and copy editors.
–When mistakes are made, editors are required to fill out a form explaining the mistake and why/how it happened.
–I’ve distributed lists of my best practices for getting things right.
–I sponsored an accuracy contest called Good Save! to create a culture that celebrates finding and fixing mistakes before they hit the paper.
–I’ve done multiple enrichments on accuracy.
–We’ve talked about taking ownership of your own work.

One Response
After all of this stuff, if there are still major problems… then I just don’t know what will help.
Some errors getting in is nothing to have to fill out a form about. A little grammar blip here, an AP style slip there, these are college newspapers and they are being written by humans who are still very much learning. Not that they are excusable, but a correction for a comma is obvious to most as overkill.
They should be pointed out and the writer made aware. For learning purposes.
I’m counting somewhere upwards of eight people reading stories before they make it to the page, according to your post. That’s good for a lot of people to get their hands on it, but maybe too many cooks in the kitchen are causing more problems than they are fixing.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.